A Long Island serial killer has confessed to killing eight women after a years-long investigation.

A long-running investigation into a high-profile case concluded in Suffolk County Court. Defendant Rex Heuerman pleaded guilty to the murders of eight women. The victims' families had been waiting for this moment for more than a decade. BBC tells the details of the high-profile case.

The long-standing story came to an end on April 8 in the hall vessels A man about 6'3", dressed in a black suit and blue tie, stood before a judge and confessed to the brutal murders of eight women.

Rex Heuerman maintained an expressionless expression. He confirmed to Judge Timothy Mazzei that he strangled and bound all his victims in the same manner. The killer then left their remains on remote beaches on Long Island.

For questions judges He mostly answered "yes." Heuermann didn't turn around to look at the room where the relatives of the victims were gathered. Some of them were struggling to hold back tears.

Long years of waiting

The victims' families waited more than a decade for this moment. The investigation into the murders, which shocked the residents of Long Island, took years.

"A lot of people talked about it—there was no taboo," said Sandra Simon, a classmate of Heuerman's. "Everyone had their own theory."

On the subject: Robber tricks his way into elderly couple's home: brutal murder shocks city

These theories ended in 2023, when police arrested Heuermann. At the time, he was married, raising two children, and living in Masapequa Park, a quiet Long Island suburb, in the house where he spent his childhood.

Arrest and charges

The 62-year-old architect was detained by Suffolk County police at his Manhattan office. Investigators linked Heuermann to the murders through DNA found on a pizza box.

He was initially charged with the murder of seven women, and on April 8 he pleaded guilty to another murder committed in 1996.

The case gained publicity in 2010, when investigators discovered four bodies about 400 meters apart on Gilgo Beach.

Casualties

Initially, Heuermann denied his guilt, but later confessed to the murders:

• Melissa Barthelemy, 24;
• Megan Waterman, 22;
• Amber Costello, 27;
• Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25;
• Jessica Taylor, 20;
• Valerie Mack, 24;
• Sandra Costilla, 28;
• Karen Vergaty, 34 years old.

All the victims are believed to have been sex workers. Some of them contacted him through Craigslist ads.

In court, Heuermann revealed few new details. He only confirmed that he lured women with promises of money. He then killed them, dismembered their bodies, and left the remains on the beach.

When asked about the method of murder, he said "strangulation." When asked if he pleaded guilty, he replied "guilty."

"There was not a shred of remorse on this man's face," John Ray, the victims' families' lawyer, said after the hearing. "He was cold as ice."

The court sentenced the defendant to multiple life sentences. The final verdict will be handed down on June 17.

During the brief hearing, Heuermann's ex-wife, Asa Ellerup, was present. She stood at the back of the room, dressed in black. Their daughter stood next to her, holding napkins.

After the trial, Ellerup said her thoughts were with the families of the victims, calling their loss "immeasurable."

The area where the killer lived

Masapequa Park is a small community on Long Island with a population of about 18,000. Its streets are hung with American flags. They are lined with well-maintained houses, and some have boats parked in their yards.

However, one of these houses always stands out. A dilapidated house with red shutters and green window frames, it's located just a block away from the home of a local named Joe.

"He doesn't fit in with our neighborhood, but what can you do..." Joe sighed. "You just don't think about it."

Once considered a neighborhood blight, this house now attracts journalists and crime buffs.

On the eve of the hearing, reporters gathered outside the house again. Heuermann's ex-wife and children, along with their lawyer, were giving comments. They were responding to a wrongful death lawsuit filed by a relative of one of the victims.

After Heuermann's arrest, his family remained in their home. They even held barbecues on the porch, despite the crowds of onlookers.

However, as the court hearing approached, residents wanted to put this incident behind them. They say it's rarely mentioned now.

"It's not breaking news anymore," Joe remarked. "American society has a short memory. I know my neighbors, but honestly, you don't really know anyone."

Criticism of the investigation

Despite Heuermann's admission, many believe it should have happened sooner.

The police investigated the case for over ten years. However, they had a tip that could have led them to the killer much sooner.

The victims' families believe the investigation was delayed because the victims were sex workers. They point out that police frequently emphasized this fact.

Some Long Island residents agree, saying they were shocked by how long it took to achieve justice.

Initially, Suffolk County police did not involve federal authorities. Those leading the investigation also found themselves at the center of controversy.

Former Police Chief James Burke was arrested in 2015 and later found guilty of charges including obstruction of justice. The case also implicated District Attorney Thomas Spota, who served from 2002 to 2017.

In 2022, under new leadership, Suffolk County Police created a task force, comprising representatives from federal and local law enforcement agencies.

It was this group that contacted Heuermann in just six weeks.

How the culprit was found

Investigators used a description of the suspect obtained back in 2010. It was provided by the roommate of one of the victims, Amber Costello.

The witness described the client as a large man, resembling an "ogre." Among other things, he mentioned a first-generation Chevrolet Avalanche.

This information helped to reach Heuerman.

Investigators then examined burner phones, cell tower data, and forensic evidence. Hair found on the victims' bodies matched samples taken from the pizza box he had discarded.

In the basement of his home, police found additional evidence, including computer notes with instructions on how to commit murder.

Unanswered questions

Despite the acknowledgement of the murders, the families of the victims and the public remain left with many questions.

The bodies of four women were discovered while authorities were searching for the remains of another victim, Shannan Gilbert. In May 2010, she called police late at night, screaming that "they" were trying to kill her.

Eileen Colletti Edwards appeared in court on April 8 on behalf of her father. He was the one who let Gilbert into his Oak Beach home the night she disappeared. She knocked on his door. He tried to call the police, but Gilbert ran away.

"He hoped she'd escaped and was hiding somewhere," noted Colletti Edwards. Her father died before Heuermann's arrest.

Police said they do not believe Heuerman was involved in Gilbert's death.

Investigators believe her death was most likely an accident. She may have drowned or perished due to the dangerous conditions in the swampy area where she was found.

The victim's family's lawsuit

Benjamin Torres, Valerie Mack's son, has filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Heuermann and his family. He hopes to recover the funds the family received from participating in the documentary.

Torres' lawyer, John Ray, noted that after his arrest, Ellerup called her husband a "hero," even though they were divorced.

However, police claim that Heuerman's family was not involved in the crimes.

On April 7, outside the Masapequa Park home, Ellerup's lawyer again emphasized that the family had nothing to do with the murders.

Are there any more victims?

Some residents wonder if the land of Long Island still holds secrets.

Every Sunday during the summer, Sandra Simon and others take a boat to Hemlock Cove, a popular boating spot near the area where Heuerman left the remains of his victims.

Sometimes people joke that it's worth taking binoculars and looking for new bodies in the nearby swamps.

However, for Simon this is no joke.

"How can you say that?" she asked in surprise. "It was terrible and scary."